

Face-off
Vinyl over, or new tiles?
The resale flat's big question. Ben takes one corner, Belle takes the other, and they meet at the tap test.
Ben's corner: vinyl, laid over
Illustration
Light oak vinyl plank
Vinyl laid over the old floor needs no HDB permit.
Nothing comes up, so there are no noisy removal days to plan around.
Karndean's conditions for laying over tiles: firm, dry and clean tiles, loose ones fixed, and grout lines wider or deeper than 5 mm levelled first.
Our typical price: S$5,100 to S$6,800 for 85 sqm.
Typical price, before extras
Our price levels · supplied and laid, GST included
Entry S$45 to S$60 · Mid S$60 to S$80 · Premium S$80 to S$120 a sqm.
Set 4 Oct 2026.
Supplied and laid on a ready, level floor, with standard installation, normal wastage and GST included. Major levelling or screeding, laying in herringbone or chevron, removing and disposing of the old floor, new skirting, special transition profiles, door trimming and other remedial work are normally extra, priced after a site inspection.
Sound tiles? Lay over them. No permit, no noisy days.
Belle's corner: new tiles
Illustration
Cream matte porcelain
Porcelain feels cool under bare feet, and a matte one keeps the 5pm light soft.
Replacing floor finishes needs an HDB permit.
Taking the old floor up is noisy work: weekdays 9am to 5pm only, and no more than 3 days in a row.
Our typical price: S$9,775 to S$13,175 for 85 sqm. Taking up and carting away the old floor is normally extra.
Cool porcelain under bare feet in June. Worth the paperwork.
Notes and sources (9)
HDB, Building works guidelines · checked 30 Sep 2026
- Laying of vinyl finishes, carpet or linoleum: no permit required.
- Replacement of floor finishes: permit required.
HDB, Renovation: important information · checked 30 Sep 2026
- Removing floor finishes is a restricted renovation, allowed only 9am to 5pm on weekdays.
- Removing floor finishes: 9am to 5pm on weekdays; no more than 3 consecutive days.
Karndean, Rigid Core plank and tile installation guide (USA) · Jan 2024
- Tiles: ensure the surface is firm, dry and free of wax, oil and dust; level any grout lines with a width or depth of more than 5 mm.
Karndean, 2G Rigid Core installation guidelines (Australia and New Zealand) · Aug 2023
- Fix any loose tiles.
SGFloorFinder price levels · our own levels
- Vinyl, typical: S$60 to S$80 per sqm (S$5.57 to S$7.43 per sq ft).
- Tiles, typical: S$115 to S$155 per sqm (S$10.68 to S$14.40 per sq ft). Removing and disposing of the old floor is normally extra.
Karndean, Frequently asked questions · undated, checked 29 Sep 2026
- Karndean, a vinyl maker, on stone and ceramic: they can feel cold when the temperature drops.